Kurdish Defiance Turns to
Victory in Kirkuk Land CaseERBIL (Kurdistan24) – In a landmark decision underscoring the complex and often fraught dynamics of land ownership in Kurdistani territories that are outside the Kurdistan Region’s administrative control, the Court of Dibis District in Kirkuk Province issued a ruling on Sunday affirming the rightful ownership of a contested plot of land by three Kurdish farmers from the village of Shenagha in the Sargaran subdistrictThe case had drawn significant local attention, stemming from a legal complaint lodged four months earlier by Arab settlers who alleged that the farmers had illegally seized the land.
The dispute, rooted in longstanding tensions over property rights and demographic engineering, saw the Kurdish farmers detained for several days by local Kirkuk authorities before being released on bail. However, following a thorough legal review and presentation of key evidence, the court concluded that the land indeed belongs to the Kurdish claimants.
Youssef Hassan Shawani, a volunteer lawyer representing the farmers, confirmed the outcome in a statement to Kurdistan24. “The court reviewed all the evidence and testimonies and ruled in favor of the Kurdish farmers,” he stated. “Witness accounts and land documents clearly demonstrated that they had legitimate ownership, while the Arab plaintiffs were found to have registered the land illegally.”
Shawani further noted that the Arab individuals who filed the lawsuit were not original inhabitants of Kirkuk, adding weight to allegations that they were part of a broader trend of post-2003 Arab settlement aimed at altering the region’s demographic composition.
The ruling has been hailed as a significant victory for Kurdish residents in the area, many of whom have faced legal and physical pressure amid ongoing disputes over land once confiscated under Saddam Hussein’s Arabization policies. Although some of that land has since been returned to its original owners, unresolved property claims continue to stoke tensions between communities.
This ruling also comes against a tense backdrop in the same village. As previously reported by Kurdistan24, tensions escalated in February when the Iraqi army attempted to forcibly prevent Kurdish farmers in Shenagha from accessing and cultivating their land.
Visual documentation captured by Kurdistan24 showed Iraqi soldiers confronting unarmed farmers, with one widely shared video showing a soldier attempting to drag a farmer off his tractor. The farmer defiantly responded, “Even if I die, I will not get down from the tractor!” — a moment that quickly became emblematic of the farmers’ resilience.
In response to the Iraqi army’s intervention, the Kurdistan Region’s leadership, including President Masoud Barzani and Prime Minister Masrour Barzani, condemned the actions as unconstitutional and reminiscent of the Ba’ath-era injustices.
President Barzani, in a powerful statement, warned that such behavior evokes “painful memories of the Anfal campaign and chemical attacks.” The Kurdistan Region Presidency and the KRG Prime Minister's Office also issued statements condemning the military interference and calling for immediate accountability
Amid the military escalation back in February, Kurdish farmers in Shenagha issued a 48-hour ultimatum to the Iraqi army to withdraw from the village, vowing to resume cultivation even if it meant risking their lives. Local and national leaders rallied to their defense, with Deputy Speaker of the Iraqi Parliament Shakhawan Abdullah relaying President Barzani’s support directly to the affected farmers.
Mohammed Ismail, a representative of the Sargaran farmers, had earlier highlighted the difficult conditions faced by local agricultural workers. “Restrictions imposed by military forces have made farming increasingly difficult,” he told Kurdistan24. “This ruling is a step in the right direction, but the broader environment remains hostile and uncertain.”
The broader implications of the Shenagha standoff and subsequent court ruling cannot be overstated. As Kurdistan24 previously reported, the Iraqi Parliament recently passed a bill aimed at returning lands confiscated under Ba’athist policies to their rightful Kurdish owners—a significant step toward reversing decades of demographic manipulation. Yet, as recent events demonstrate, legal reforms alone are insufficient without enforcement and institutional restraint.
The court’s decision is expected to set an important legal precedent for future land disputes in Kirkuk and other disputed areas. It also underscores the critical need for continued vigilance, media scrutiny, and legal advocacy in ensuring justice for communities historically marginalized by state policies.
While the case may be closed in court, the larger question of land justice in Kirkuk remains unresolved, with many Kurdish families still seeking restitution for lands lost during decades of forced displacement and demographic manipulation. Kurdistan24 remains committed to reporting these developments and giving voice to the communities on the front lines of this enduring struggle.
https://www.kurdistan24.net/en/story/83 ... -land-case